Last half of the Cody Walker recall petitions

Let's get right to the heart of the problem.  391 signatures were validated on Mayor Todd Jirsa's recall petition.  The great majority of people who signed Mayor Todd Jirsa's recall petition also signed Mayor Pro-Tem Cody Walker's recall petition.  So the great majority of these 391 validated signatures were comprised of names of people who also signed the Cody Walker recall petition.

The Cody Walker recall petition needed 450 valid signatures to proceed to a special election.  Yet here is the tricky part.  At a minimum (let's say all the valid signatures on Mayor Todd Jirsa's petitions were also valid signatures on Mayor Pro-Tem Cody Walker's petitions), there would need to be 59 people MINIMUM who ONLY signed Cody Walker's petition (and all of them would have to be valid) in order to get to 450 valid signatures.  And there weren't this many people who ONLY signed Cody Walker's recall petition without signing Todd Jirsa's recall petition.

You say, well, what's the trick - The newspaper reported that Cody Walker's petition had 454 valid signatures.  The only way for that to happen is if, among those people who signed both petitions, the time they signed Cody Walker's petition was declared valid, and the time they signed Todd Jirsa's petition was declared invalid.  How is that possible?  Well, I suppose it is possible if, subjectively, one name's appearance on one petition was declared valid, and that same name's appearance on another petition was declared invalid (and needing curation, or rejected because it was signed after the notary validated that particular packet, for example).

This will be difficult for a judge to accept, because subjectivity should not enter in to what signatures are declared valid or invalid, especially in the case where the same person's name is counted on one set of petitions, but rejected from another set of petitions.  The plot thickens...

Note:  Of the 19 petitions that follow, 255 of the 266 signers of the petition also signed the mayoral recall petition.  The double asterisk ** indicates a name that appears on both the Cody Walker recall petition and the Todd Jirsa recall petition


Petition #12

12-16-324. **Bailey, Verd R. 540 West Elkhorn B-3
12-10-318. **Boatman, Janet E. 2102 Ute Court
12-17-325. **Bruner, Frank Warren 710 Moraine Avenue
12-18-326. **Dahl, Denise J. 1758 Red Tail Hawk Drive (see 23-10-507)
12-13-321. **Downing, Elaine M. 1066 Pine Knoll Drive
12-14-322. **Edwards, Karin Jo 1020 Acacia Drive
12-27-335. **Evans, Mary Faith 520 Riverrock Circle
12-19-327. **Galyan, Robert H. 347 Turquoise Trail
12-22-330. **Gerber, Vincent J. 233 Big Horn Drive
12-8-316. Haines, Theodora A. 1943 Wildfire
12-28-336. **Heiberger Christine 1260 Graves Avenue
12-12-320. **Henry, David A. 1931 Crags Court
12-5-313. **Kochevar, Katherine Marie 1885 Sketch Box Lane
12-25-333. **Lockman, Sandra K. 1310 Manford Avenue G-3
12-15-323. **McDonald, Christina 1920 Graham Lane
12-2-310. **McFarlane, Arlene M. 1405 Cedar Lane
12-24-332. Miller, Michael R. 3403 Eagle Cliff Circle
12-23-331. **Nielson, Dwight Ford 315 Parkview Lane
12-26-334. **O’Farrell, Edward G. 280 Old Man Mountain Lane
12-1-309. **O’Neil, Mary L. 1437 Raven Circle G
12-11-319. **Reiser, Ann M. 1655 Gray Hawk Court
12-20-328. **Reveley, Christopher 665 Freeland Court
12-6-314. **Schonlau, Anna 1759 High Pine Drive
12-4-312. **Steinbacher, Mira B. 1254 Community Drive Apartment E
12-9-317. **Towns, Sandra D. 1910 Crags Court
12-7-315. **Weniger, Kristen Lue 1600 Wapiti Circle #56
12-3-311. **Williams, Robin 692 Moreau Lane
12-21-329. **Young, Robert A. 656 Halbach

Note:  26 of the 28 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #13

13-3-339. Cline, Oakley 1031 Morgan Street (dated 4/16)
13-2-338. **Greene, Kyle M. 343 South St. Vrain (dated 4/15)
13-1-337. **Leymaster, Jane A. 138 Stanley Circle Drive

Note:  2 of the 3 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #14

14-21-360. **Baldivia, Verona L. 885 Crabapple Lane
14-27-366. **Baney, Beverly 1600 Wapiti Circle
14-22-361. **Bhatti, Tariq Hussain 887 Crabapple Lane
14-6-345. **Blevins, Patricia A. 1590 Raven Avenue Unit D
14-7-346. **Blevins, Virgil A. 1590 Raven Avenue #D
14-13-352. **Blume, Patricia D. 651 Cedar Ridge Circle
14-17-356. Brewer, David L. 1000 Elk Trail Court
14-25-364. **Brojcin, Ofelia 1947 Wildfire Road
14-20-359. **Brown, Vance 875 Crabapple Lane
14-18-357. **Burgess, Janet B. 1807 Ptarmigan Trail
14-14-353. **Coker, Sandra J. 450 Aspen Avenue
14-24-363. **Cramer, Patrick O. II 1935 Wildfire Road
14-11-350. **Fernalld, Carolyn 2095 Grey Fox Drive
14-12-351. **Fernalld, Clifford S., Jr. 2905 Grey Fox Drive
14-28-367. **Griffin, Charles N. 1600 Wapiti Circle Unit 53
14-1-340. **Harbroe, Jodi 1885 Red Tail Hawk Drive
14-3-342. **Ingalls, Mary 1754 Red Tail Hawk Drive (dated 10 March 2019) (see 30-24-588)
14-23-362. **Knolton, Barry 1741 Wildfire Road (name and date and address strongly crossed out) (see 1-20-20)
14-2-341. **Mastron, Vickie 1855 Red Tail Hawk Drive
14-26-365. **Ortega, Joseph A. 1913 Wildfire Road
14-16-355. **Papineau, Ricky L. 1711 Dekker Circle
14-5-344. **Pearson, Carol R. 1590 Raven Avenue Unit E
14-4-343. **Peters, Robyn 1590 Raven Avenue Unit I
14-10-349. **Seaver, Pamela A. 1508 Raven Circle
14-15-354. **Seckman, Larry 543 Grand Estates Drive
14-9-348. **Stephenson, Jacelyn 2011 Ptarmigan Trail
14-8-347. **Stephenson, Keith 2011 Ptarmigan Trail
14-19-358. **Underwood, Susan H. 891 Crabapple Lane

Note: 26 of the 27 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #15

15-1-368. **Allbritten, Isaac Wesley 845 Old Ranger Drive
15-3-370. Bissell, Carol M. 1884 Devils Gulch Road (no date, information crossed out heavily)
15-17-384. **Bertucci, Sarah 1620 Gray Hawk Court
15-21-388. **Bortolini, Margaret 151 Raven Circle #C
15-14-381. **Bowers, David A. 1360 Raven Circle #H
15-8-375. **Coleman, Walter F. 1600 Wapiti Circle Unit #54
15-22-389. **Dempsey, Gary 1520 Raven Circle Unit I
15-25-392. **Ellis, Carla 1520 Raven Court Unit B
15-9-376. **Emerine, Terry W. 1600 Wapiti Circle unit 31 (or similar, first number illegible)
15-7-374. **Griffin, Linda E. 1600 Wapiti Circle Unit 53
15-13-380. **Haglund, Pamella 1457 Matthew Circle
15-15-382. **Henderson, Karla A. 258 Steamer Court
15-19-386. **Hiney, Gregory 1770 Gray Hawk Court
15-16-383. **Kostadinov, Alexandor 1675 Gray Hawk Court
15-4-371. Leavitt, Nancy M. or similar 2550 Devils Gulch Road (dated 3/20/2019) (crossed out heavily)
15-12-379. **Miller, Don E. 1452 Matthew Circle
15-24-491. **Neely-Turpin, Shirley 1520 Raven Court Unit F
15-5-372. **Sampson, Mary Alice 633 Park River Place
15-2-369. **Schreiner, Brenda A. 465 Pine River Lane (see 11-3-283)
15-18-385. **Scott, Jesse 1720 Grey Hawk Court
15-6-373. **Shaw, Robert M. 2012 Ptarmigan Trail
15-11-378. **Sherrill, Janet 1600 Wapiti Circle #7 (date and address switched on lines provided for them)
15-20-387. **Steward, Mary Lee 2018 Ptarmigan Trail
15-23-390. **Turpin, Arthur R. 1520 Raven Court, F
15-10-377. **Van Ryn, Terry L. 1600 Wapiti Circle #26

Note:  22 of the 22 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #16

16-23-415. **Arellano, Raul 1310 Manford Avenue
16-24-416. **Baker, Philip J. 1411 Sierra Sage
16-10-402. **Baker, Robert 2050 South Morris Court
16-18-411. **Barham, Diana 1861 Raven Avenue J-2
16-17-409. **Bowers, Kathryn S. 1360 Raven Circle Unit H
16-9-401. **Bryson, Jon 1152 West Elkhorn Avenue
16-12-404. **Dahl, James D. 1758 Red Tail Hawk Drive (see 23-11-508)
16-14-406. **Gonzales, Aliya 160 Evergreen Lane
16-13-405. **Hertel, Jacquelyn M. 150 Indian Trail
16-15-407. **Holdorf Janet D. 1050 South St. Vrain H-1
16-16-408. **Hurst, Kay A. 1050 South St. Vrain L7
16-3-395. **Johnson, Irrina A. 2855 Grey Fox Drive
16-17-410. **Kienker, Delynn 2901 Carriage Drive
16-26-418. Klein, Jesika A. 270 Cyteworth Road
16-25-417. **Klein, Thomas T. 270 Cyteworth Road
16-5-397. **Lovejoy, Craig A. 2645 Grey Fox Drive
16-22-414. **McCown, Darra 2504 Carriage Drive
16-8-400. **Michener, Audra 1010 Acacia Drive
16-1-393. **Mitchell, Connie L. 1375 Raven Circle
16-7-399. **Montelbano, George T. 1901 Wildfire Road
16-11-403. **Nadeem, Robbie 1290 Strong Avenue (name and signature on wrong lines)
16-4-396. **Olsen, Jon L. 1907 Wildfire Road
16-6-398. **Peacock, Sandra J. 2645 Grey Fox Drive
16-2-394. **Peterson, Layne 1375 Raven Circle (address on incorrect line)
16-21-413. **Rojas, Jose Carmen 519 Columbine Avenue
16-20-412. **Zelinger, Stephen N. 148 Willowstone Drive (see 2-13-41)

Note: 24 of the 25 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #17

17-1-419. **Allbritten, Lois Eileen 845 Old Ranger Drive
17-3-421. **Blume, Arthur W. III 651 Cedar Ridge Circle
17-23-441. **Brazelton, Kathy 636 Aspen Avenue
17-5-423. **Brewer, Loretta A. 1000 Elk Trail Court
17-13-431. **Brien, Ward 2050 Jacob Road (is Jacob Road within Estes Park town limits?)
17-12-430. **Buck, Patricia A. 425 Chapin Lane
17-27-445. **Conkling, John G. 1927 Wildfire Road
17-26-444. **Conkling, Lisa A. 1927 Wildfire Road
17-28-446. **Conley, Allison 1619 Soaring Circle
17-11-429. **Conrad, Heidi T. 2240 Arapaho Road
17-6-424. Czapp, David M. 334 Virginia Drive
17-24-442. **Dennis, Kevin 621 Chapin
17-16-434. **Hanna, Maggie 332 Ute Lane
17-14-432. **Hanna, Thomas L. 332 Ute Lane
17-9-427. **Leverton, Elizabeth R. 101 Ute Lane
17-8-426. **Leverton, Roger W. 101 Ute Lane
17-22-440. **MacCord, Marie E. 1155 South St. Vrain Avenue Apt A6
17-18-436. **Meylor, Pamela M. 3000 Lakota Court
17-15-433. **Michener, Ravit 2158 Uplands Circle
17-17-435. **Paulbeck, Joan 1011 Lexington
17-10-428. **Rivard-Baker, Cheryl (or similar) 1411 Sierra Sage Lane
17-7-425. **Schaps, John J. 909 Village Green Lane
17-4-422. Seckman, Cynthia M. 543 Grand Estates Drive
17-21-439. **Sigrist, Renee A. 517 Driftwood Avenue #1
17-19-437. **Spomer, Darcy A. 1011 Lexington Lane
17-20-438. **Springer, Ronald W. 676 Park River Place
17-25-443. **Spencer, Dayle E. 1880 Sleepy Hollow Court
17-2-420. **Webermeier, John Scott 412 Steele Court

Note:  26 of the 28 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #18

18-2-448. **Fritz, Bill 575 Devon Drive
18-9-455. **Gribble, Deborah 825 Fawn Lane
18-8-454. **Gribble, Dennis H. 825 Fawn Lane
18-1-447. **Harger, Mary Lou 1910 Baldpate Court
18-4-450. **Hoffman, Robert M. II 865 Fawn Lane
18-5-451. **Hoffman, Lynn C. 865 Fawn Lane
18-7-453. **Johnson, James L. 560 Devon Drive
18-6-452. **Johnson, Lynette R. 560 Devon Drive
18-3-449. **Willner, Maren 600 Mocassin Circle Drive (is this the correct spelling of Moccasin?)

Note:  9 of the 9 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #19

19-1-456. **Colburn, Sherry L. 112 Ute Lane
19-2-457. **Higley, Christann K. 751 Longs Drive

Note:  2 of the 2 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #20

20-1-458. **Ash, Melanie Roddam 1769 Wildfire Road
20-3-460. Van Drie, Gladys 869 Crabapple Lane
20-2-459. Van Drie, Karla 869 Crabapple Lane

Note:  1 of the 3 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #21

21-12-472. **Adams, Arthur Riley 1776 Olympian Lane Unit G
21-11-471. **Barringer, Mike 1776 Olympian Lane Unit E
21-6-466. **Bryson, Donna M. 570 Darcy Drive
21-7-467. **Bryson, Michael L. 570 Darcy Drive
21-14-474. **Casson, Gloria G. 690 Bird Circle
21-5-465. **Cook, Tammara L. 310 Virginia Drive #3
21-15-475. **Francis, Deborah L. 287 South Court
21-18-478. **Giron, Lilian/Liliana 659 Morgan Street (signed on 4/16 with two different first names - signature versus legal name)
21-17-477. **Hoffman, Barbara M. 401 Ridge View Lane
21-16-476. **Hoffman, Wesley E. 401 Ridgevie [sic, likely Ridgevue or Ridgeview] Lane
21-8-468. **Marshall, Elizabeth T. 1980 Baldpate Court
21-1-461. **McWhinney, Sabina 345 Kiowa Drive (date, name, and address crossed out)
21-3-463. **Murphy, John G. 220 Old Man Mountain Drive
21-2-462. **Reinertsen, Nathan 232 East Riverside Drive
21-10-470. **Sackett, Karen 518 Riverrock Circle
21-9-469. **Slicker, Charles C. 1940 North Sharon Court
21-4-464. **Speedlin, Sara 1940 Baldpate Court
21-13-473. **Whalen, Christian 1065 Morgan Street (on the mayor's petition, this looks more like Whalen, Christopher 1085 Morgan Street)

Note:  17 of the 17 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #22

22-6-484. **Bell, Carolyn L. 1903 Wildfire Road
22-5-483. **Bell, Jon L. 1903 Wildfire Road
22-7-485. **Finley, Ann 775 Freeland Court
22-8-486. **Fridrich, Arthur J. 1776 D Olympian Lane
22-9-487. **Gebhardt, Barbara L. 384 Pro Bono Prospect Estates (Barbara Gebhardt has requested her address be removed from a searchable database)
22-3-481. **Shank, Chanler 1923 Wildfire Road
22-4-482. **Shank, Steve 1923 Wildfire Road
22-1-479. Thut, John 1929 Wildfire Road
22-2-480. **Thut, Nancy 1929 Wildfire Road

Note:  8 of the 9 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #23

23-5-492. **Bauer, Rae M. 877 Crabapple Lane
23-10-497. **Dahl, Denise J. 1758 Red Tail Hawk Drive (see 12-18-326)
23-11-498. **Dahl, James D. 1758 Red Tail Hawk Drive (see 16-12-414)
23-8-495. **Dixon, Brenda 876 Crabapple Lane
23-7-494. **Dixon, James R. 876 Crabapple Lane
23-9-496. **Jensen, Amber 1760 Gray Hawk Court
23-6-493. **Montgomery, Jeremy S. 885 Crabapple Lane
23-2-489. **Petrocine, Cora E. 645 Pinewood Lane
23-1-488. **Sohocki, Dana 1900 Gray Hawk Court
23-3-490. **Taylor, Marcia M. 640 MacGregor Avenue #10
23-4-491. **Wright, Beverly C. 315 Kiowa Drive

Note:  9 of the 9 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #24

24-1-499. **Krall, Dolores Josephine 1904 Ptarmigan Trail
24-2-500. **Lee, Randall G. 1659 High Pine Drive
24-3-501. **Osterman, Sandra Lynn 1731 Red Tail Hawk Drive
(Note:  Notary page in this petition is upside down)

Note:  3 of the 3 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #26

26-2-503. **Bender, Donald D. 475 Prospector Lane
26-1-502. **Bender, Martha H. 475 Prospector Lane
26-18-520. **Bostron, John P. 1886 Fall River Road
26-5-506. **Budhutreti, Bromesh (as with the mayoral recall petition, where it was “deciphered” as “Budweiser, Branch” this name is essentially illegible) 418 Stanley Avenue
26-19-521. **Fraser, Celeste 1934 Bradley Lane
26-7-509. **Gallagher, Robert W. Jr. 546 #C Driftwood Avenue
26-16-518. **Goetzel, Ruth 1141 Fall River Drive
26-13-515. **Harless, Billy W. 561 Grand Estates
26-15-517. **Holler, Vicky 385 Park View Lane
26-7-508. **Jennings, Vicki 2970 Lakota Court
26-12-514. **Johnson, Richard A. 1281 High Drive and 1650 Brook Court (why two addresses?)
26-4-505. **Mitchell, Buddy 1965 Cherokee Drive
26-10-512. **Palace, Red 161 Evergreen Lane (physical address written twice, only once in correct place)
26-17-519. **Stevanus, Carey 1886 Fall River Road
26-11-513. **Stoykova, Antoniya 220 East Elkhorn Avenue
26-9-511. **Swoboda, Gary L. 1964 Cherokee Drive
26-14-516. **Tekulve, Richard D. 1028 Tranquil Lane
26-3-504. **Wallis, Kendra L. 1410 Sierra Sage Lane
26-8-510. **Warren, Michael P. 1303 Kinnikinnic Court
26-6-507. **Warren, Renee J. 1303 Kinnikinnic Court

Note:  20 of the 20 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #27

27-1-522. **Beechy, Judith A. 315 Big Horn Drive Unit H
27-4-525. **Centurione, Dan J. 566 Darcy Drive
27-3-524. **Gordon, Michelle J. 1210 Fairway Club Circle #2
27-2-523. **Lee, Michael F. 311 Far View Drive

Note:  4 of the 4 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #28

28-21-546. **Armstrong, Drew 514 Grand Estates Drive A2
28-9-534. **Baker, Kara Moore 2050 South Morris Court
28-17-542. **Barrett, Izorah S. 1605 Ziola Court #10
28-6-531. **Beesley, Claire H. 411 Pawnee Lane
28-2-527. **DeJoseph, Sandra J. 1600 Wapiti Circle Unit 44
28-3-528. **Dersham, Michael 811 Spring Street
28-28-553. **Fleet, Cynthia A. 1199 Holiday Lane
28-4-529. **Hayden, Carol Jean Short 851 Black Canyon Drive
28-23-548. **Jandrain, Scott F. 423 Stanley Avenue
28-1-526. **Keilty, Michael 2441 Arapaho Road
28-10-535. **Lande, Vanessa E. 1920 Baldpate Court
28-22-547. **Mack, Stacy 1861 Raven Avenue A-3
28-8-533. **Moore, Kae A. 2041 South Morris Court
28-27-552. **Moreau, Philip 211 Fourth Street
28-13-538. **Placek, Joseph F. 1260 Graves Avenue #26
28-16-541. **Scruton, Diane L. 1401 Deer Path Court
28-15-540. **Scruton, Leon R. 1401 Deer Path Court
28-18-543. **Settje, Mary A. 1550 Raven Circle Unit A
28-14-539. **Shamblin, Kerry S. 220 Fall River Lane
28-24-549. **Shipman, Greg 625 Park River Place
28-19-544. Shirk, Marie Esla Miner (name crossed out, no address provided)
28-20-545. **Shirk, Marie Esla Miner 301 Far View Drive

28-25-550. **Swim, Steven W. 509-5 Grand Estates
28-5-530. **Tekulve, Judith A. 1028 Tranquil Lane
28-12-537. **Towns, Thomas R. 1910 Crags Court
28-7-532. **Vertreese, Karen 1991 South Morris
28-26-551. **White, Michiah 151 West Riverside Drive (does this address even exist?)
28-11-536.  **Willner, Richard E. 1121 Scott Avenue

Note:  27 of the 27 signers of these two petitions also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #29

29-1-554. **Foy, Suzan 2809 Fish Creek Road
29-3-556. **Leigh, Anna P. 540 Big Horn Drive
29-2-555. **Leigh, Thomas E. 540 Big Horn Drive

Note:  3 of the 3 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition

Petition #30

30-27-583. **Bradford, Lori J. 1109 Brook Drive
30-26-582. **Bradford, William A. 1109 Brook Drive
30-17-573. **Burkhardt, Robert 400 Parkview Lane
30-20-576. **Conley, Nancy 1893 Redtail Hawk
30-9-565. **Conway, Deborah L. 1749 Wildfire Road
30-6-562. **Cormack, Cynthia D. (printed legal name above line) 1010 South St. Vrain #C6
30-14-570. **Crockett, Joan C. 513 Riverrock Circle
30-16-572. **Ellard, Kathleen 2211 Big Horn Drive
30-12-568. **Gillespie, Mary S. 755 Elm Road Unit 11
30-21-577. **Harris, Ronald Dale 2198 Governors Lane
30-1-557. **Holmes, Donald L. 210 Second Street
30-2-558. **Hulsing, Darel J. 1743 Avalon Drive
30-24-580. **Ingalls, Mary M. 1754 Red Tail Hawk Drive (see 14-3-342)
30-4-560. **Jones, Alexandra P. 935 High Acres Drive
30-11-567. **Lynch, Brian 2120 Fall River Road
30-7-563. **May, Barbara J. 1175 Fish Creek Road
30-15-571. McDonald, Tamlin 2030 Monida Court
30-18-574. **Pritchett, Penelope J. 1411 Vail Court
30-19-575. **Pritchett, Robert, Jr. 1411 Vail Court
30-28-584. **Racine, David 461 Big Horn Drive
30-10-566. **Rodriguez, Jenna 1755 Highway 66 (Moraine Avenue)
30-23-579. **Santana, Erika 932 Peak View Drive
30-5-561. **Schuman, Teresa 2341 Larkspur Avenue
30-13-569. **Stepniak, Dennis J. 1082 Fall River Court
30-22-578. **Strom, D. Susan 1660 High Pine Drive
30-8-564. **Wagner, Linda K. 950 Comanche St. Unit C
30-3-559. **Weston, Mark 2171 Governors Lane
30-25-581. **Winokur, Christine 2040 South Morris Court

Note:  26 of the 27 signers of this petition also signed the mayoral recall petition


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Johanna writes

I'm always fascinated by the question of why Marie Cenac entered local politics

Okay so I'll say it